For Replacement Value, it would be a huge expense to make it look like a stolen bike. Oem bikes have nice paint jobs, and you are not even changing a color: only a texture.
Like someone referenced, there may be a good reason for the textures offered. I've only had one black bike, and it was repainted (gloss black.) It was not dry yet in a couple of months after repainting before I waxed it, and it was perpetually soft paint afterwards. Black paint highlights all imperfections. Good luck!