Mine Shad is cool. But as i heard Givi is really better in quality. With higher prices too.
I took something cheaper, to fit my wallet, but if you really wants great quality you should choose Givi. Shad is good. But GIVI is higher.
And ofc don't take crappy cheap no-name budget one, you would regret it one day.
So this is a Shad 45. I think my old top case on KLR was 35 liters volume. But i don't regret this size, it never annoyed me yet and i like to fit closely and slowly between stopped cars at each red/stop light (roads are small here ). It's alway the handbars who are hard to fit, not the top box.
And a large top box will protect rear of your bike if you fall. And huge winter jacket with more.... will fit in. Or summer jacket+helmet.
I like the white "light reflector" at the back, looks good.
I alrdy put pretty heavy charge like 8 coca bottle and stuff so 12-14 kg.
Can't tell you if it will last for years, as i have it only for a month. But my last Shad was good for 10years. But was smaller size.
Key system working perfectly.
There is flexible straps inside to avoid things moving.
I paid 180€ total, with a -30% special deal on the fitting.
Well, if it can helps : the fitting system is very good and solid quality and easy to fix. I have chosen to screw the top box to the fitting because, first, i don't need to separate them, but especially to avoid any top box stealing. So, obviously, it's pretty solid now xD
(i hadn't screwed old one to the fitting, on my KLR, and np )
But hey ! if u don't mind the price difference, take a GIVI !